Adobe Firefly, Joute's review

The essentials

• Adobe's generative AI suite, trained only on licensed or public-domain data
• Firefly plan at 9 €/month, included in some Creative Cloud plans
• Native integration in Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere and Express
• The most legally safe option for commercial use

What is Adobe Firefly?

Firefly is Adobe's generative AI suite. It includes text-to-image generation, generative fill in Photoshop (inpainting and canvas extension), recoloring in Illustrator and other AI features across the Creative Cloud ecosystem. The differentiating proposition: Firefly was trained only on Adobe Stock licensed content, open-license works and public domain. Adobe commits to indemnifying customers if copyright issues arise.

Strengths

Legal safety for commercial use

That's argument number one. On commercial projects, using content generated by AIs trained on web-scraped data exposes you to legal risk. Firefly is the safest option currently available.

Native Photoshop and Illustrator integration

Photoshop's generative fill (generate a background, extend an image, remove an element) is one of the most powerful workflows on the market. The integration is fluid and productive.

Results coherent with professional ecosystem

Firefly generates images in styles that fit well into professional design workflows. Less artistically spectacular than Midjourney, more usable in a production context.

Limits

Artistic quality below Midjourney

For pure artistic creation, Midjourney produces more impressive results. Firefly is strong on the utility side, less on creative aesthetics.

Credits consumed quickly

The Firefly credit system can be exhausted quickly in intensive use, especially on high-resolution features.

Pricing

Firefly plan at 9 €/month with monthly credits. Included in some Creative Cloud plans. Check adobe.com for details based on your current sub.

Alternatives

Adobe Firefly = legally safe generative AI. Alternative Midjourney (midjourney.com) = 10 €/month, superior artistic quality. Alternative Canva (canva.com) = 12 €/month, more accessible for non-designers.

Verdict

Firefly is the reference choice for agencies and professionals producing commercial content who need legal coverage. If you already work in Photoshop or Illustrator, the integration is undeniable. For personal artistic creation or projects where legal risk is lower, Midjourney offers better quality.

FAQ

Does Adobe stand behind Firefly content against copyright claims?

Yes, Adobe offers an indemnification guarantee for commercial use of content generated by Firefly Enterprise. Consumer version terms are less extensive.

Is Firefly included in Photoshop?

Basic Firefly features are included in Photoshop plans. Additional credits and advanced features require a specific Firefly subscription.

Can Firefly generate text inside images?

Yes, Firefly has invested in generating readable text inside images, a historical weak point of most generators.

Is Firefly quality comparable to DALL-E?

The two sit in the same quality segment. Firefly is stronger on Creative Suite integration, DALL-E on complex prompt understanding.

Joute may earn a commission on subscriptions taken out through links in this article. This does not affect our opinions.